STARTING OVER (1979: Dir. Alan J. Pakula)
Now that he had become the number one box office star in the world Burt Reynolds longed to put his acting chops to the test in a role that revealed the truth behind his ladies man image. He found it in television sitcom creator James L. Brooks' (The Mary Tyler Moore Show) first theatrical screenplay Starting Over. But despite his popular status he still had to audition for director Alan J. Pakula in order to secure the role of Phil Potter, a divorced part-time teacher pining for his narcissistic ex-wife (Candice Bergen). Burt has admitted that Potter is the closest he has ever come to revealing himself on-screen and it is certainly one of his bravest characterizations, one that walks the knife's edge between self-involvement and pity. By turns vulnerable, neurotic, charming, and pathetic, Burt, in a mustache-free performance, creates a totally believable portrait of an average man in mid-life crisis. He is evenly matched opposite his former Semi-Tough co-star Jill Clayburgh as the new woman in his life, a nursery school teacher recovering from her own failed relationship. Hers is a portrayal of such compelling strength of character and emotional sensitivity that she even threatens to win over the viewer's allegiance, in a battle of wills constantly challenged by the Burt's maladroit handling of their affair. For her memorable work, Clayburgh was awarded her second Best Actress Oscar nomination in a row. As an hilarious blithely off-key songstress, Bergen was also nominated, in the Best Supporting Actress category. Not surprisingly, Burt's sensitive portrayal was taken for granted by the Academy as well as by most critics, although the film did signal his future preferences for romantic comedies over the stunt-filled popcorn pictures that had brought him to the pinnacle of world stardom. He would remain at the top for three more years but he would never enjoy a leading role of such depth for rest of his career. DVD REGION 1 & 2